The (In)efficiency of Perfect Price Discrimination

Jan 13 11:01 2018 Print This Article

I have always thought, and taught, that Perfect Price Discrimination leads to an efficient allocation of resources. I now think that is wrong. It only seems to work if we use partial equilibrium reasoning, for a single monopolist that practices PPD, holding constant consumers' income and the monopolist's Marginal Cost curve. It doesn't work in general equilibrium. And the easiest way to see this is to construct a counterexample where all consumption goods are produced by monopolists who practice PPD, while the labour market is perfectly competitive.

A PPD monopolist captures 99.99% of Consumers' Surplus by setting a different price for each apple for each consumer, that is 99.99% of that consumer's Willingness To Pay for that apple, down to where the marginal price equals the Marginal Cost of producing an extra apple. So the consumer buys all the apples up to the point where his marginal Willingness to Pay (Marginal Benefit) equals Marginal Cost, but is almost at the point of walking away from the deal and not buying any apples at all. It looks like it works to get an efficient allocation of resources (where Marginal Benefit equals Marginal Cost) if we think partial equilibrium.

Read More

About Article Author

A Worthwhile Canadian Initiative

Group economics blog written by Canadian Economics professors and authors from the University of Laval, Carleton University, Richard Ivey School of Business, and Lakehead University

  Categories:

Related Items

This Entertainment Leader is Still Crushing It

The S&P 500 fell to its lowest level since early July and pierced its 200-day moving average last week. Chartists looking for stocks that held up better during this decline can use these levels for comparison. Stocks that did not break below their August lows and 200-day moving averages held up bet ...

Won’t it be cheaper to buy pot from my regular dealer?

You’re likely to find cheaper pot on the illicit market. “That’s not surprising,” said Trina Fraser, partner and head of the CannaLaw group at Ottawa-based Brazeau Seller Law. “The illegal market will drop its prices to undercut the legal one. What we’re hearing is that illegal prices h ...

Welcome to 'Analyzing India'!

I seize this opportunity to welcome you all to this Blog "Analyzing India". It is beyond all doubts that India remains one of the most important global markets. Out of all the Emerging Markets (EMs), the world's largest democracy certainly remains the most promising one. As a brief introduc ...

Asia market update : Focus on Yuan

Asia market update: Focus on Yuan   Surprising busy start even with the absence of Hong Kong in the mix The hawkish warm-up ahead of tonight’s FOMC minutes delivered by San Francisco’s new President Daly is creating some noise today after she said late in the NY session she does think it’s a ...

Daily Markets Broadcast 2018-10-17

Daily Markets Broadcast 2018-10-17 Wall Street boosted by strong earnings US indices saw a solid rally yesterday, boosted by strong earnings reports from the likes of Goldman Sachs, Johnson & Johnson and Netflix, while strong economic data also helped sentiment. All indices have regained the 200-d ...

Marijuana Stocks, Market Declines, and Investor Q&A

With the recent decline in markets and upcoming marijuana legalization in Canada, many investors are asking questions (some very hopeful, while others very fearful). To help address this, we are launching a monthly market update video. The goal is to keep you informed on what is happening in the ...

Is it too late to cash in on the pot stock boom?

As recreational pot becomes legal, it’s natural to think about investing in the cannabis industry. Some people have already gotten filthy rich trading in pot stocks, but you are late to the party. Have all the profits already been reaped or should you join in? Investment specialists say there is ...

Drawing down retirement savings as a single senior

Q: As I approach the early days of my retirement, I am considering various drawdown scenarios. I am single and will soon turn 61. As additional background I have a DB pension. I have approximately $170,000 in RRSPs and am considering withdrawing from these before my TFSA and non-registered investm ...

Will the global stock sell-off continue?

It was yet another week in which I felt like we lived 100 weeks. Of course the biggest event was the stock market sell-off. U.S. stocks led what became a global sell-off, which slowed and actually began to reverse on Friday. The key question on investors’ minds is: Is this over? Or will stocks lo ...